Posted by
ClearCommentary.com on Tuesday, March 27, 2007 2:57:45 PM
Religious schisms typically occur when the moral fault lines become so conspicuously burdensome that a prospective breach is seen as worth the pain in light of the long-term vision of a renewal of fundamental precepts. As reported in today's Gazette, here in Colorado Springs, the leaders of one of the state's largest Episcopal churches voted to break with the denomination over an irreconcilable ideological divide.
Following the lead of many other Episcopal churches in America, Grace Church and St. Stephen's Parish has renounced the liberal trajectory that the U.S. Episcopal Church has taken and joined the Convocation of Anglicans of North America, which ascribes to traditional beliefs, in particular in the area of human sexuality.
Noteworthy in Gazette's article are assertions by liberal church leaders that homosexuals are welcome because "they live lives of great faithfulness and holiness." However, when our chosen behavior contravenes the core principles and guiding moral precepts that inform our religion the presence or absence of holiness is not at issue.
We have observed that in our contemporary culture, compared with assault or wanton neglect, exercising one's judgment in a rational way is tantamount to felonious behavior, because to do so inevitably creates a hierarchical scale, and that confers an inferior status to some people, cultures, or religions.
Political differences are usually resolved--or at least addressed--in elections, and although there are elements of the democratic process in religious organizations, they differ fundamentally in character by their adherence to an inviolable set of moral principles. That translates into a body governed not by a civic plebiscite but by authority--another word that send shivers down the collective spine of liberals.
Moving deeper into the core of this issue, we are obliged to confront the central premise: That is, whether it's the U.S. Constitution, the Catechism of the Catholic Church, or the core beliefs of the Episcopalian Church, do we believe these principles are timeless or should they be susceptible to the vagaries of cultural influences?
Arguments that support such an approach typically argue that human knowledge is always expanding, as is our scientific understanding and technological advancements; therefore, the application of moral and ethical standards must evolve in concert with those changes.
In that regard, we hear liberals argue that our Founding Fathers could not have envisioned the machine gun and so they could not have had that in mind when they wrote the Second Amendment. Although adult stem cell research is far more promising, the left argues that embryonic stem cell research should be pursued and that a loving God would not what us to halt that inquiry because it may help those with degenerative diseases.
The list is as endless as it is subject to abuse, and therein lies the problem. To wit, the adroit application of arguments founded in a relativistic interpretation of moral absolutes is guaranteed to produce moral anarchy because, in the process, the unambiguous authority that is obtained by adherence to principle rapidly fragments, and exceptions--which are Hydra-like in their genesis--become the rule.
A corollary argument in this vein is that at the moment of its inception Protestantism itself created the moral genetics for its own incremental degeneration. When the human intellect, which is so often at the mercy of its moral imagination, is unmoored from a core set of beliefs, the results are as myriad and disconcerting as the universe itself. So it is that there is a Protestant religion for every flavor of human understanding, and, not unlike biological evolution, they are incessantly being created and are dying based on the fluctuations of human caprice.
That secondary argument aside, we whole heartedly support this development among the conservative Episcopal faithful because fractures lead to realignments and renewed energy, which is to say, a return to the basics. As such, although the process will be painful, the results will be a reinvigorated Episcopalian Church, confident that it stands on the kind of principle that has withstood the test of time.